An ODI is being played in India . It is the 40th over.
First or second innings, it doesn’t matter. Suresh Raina gets out.
A moment of silence from the crowd. A moment of
jubilation for the opposition team.
Emphasis on A MOMENT. After that the situation is
reversed for the crowd and the opposition team.
Why?
MS Dhoni walks in. This has been the case
for years now (well, not the Raina getting out part). And he has been living
up to their expectation more often than not.
Dhoni isn't a technically gifted batsman as compared
to other batsman in team.
Then why this expectation? This is because he knows
how to play those big moments in the game better than the most. It also helps
being one of the best finishers of the game.
Here are some stats to prove my point
There have been 82 matches won by India while
chasing which included Dhoni who has batted on 58 occasions out of which he has
been not-out in 38 matches. All in all he averages 109 in matches that he has
won batting second. One might say that lots of not-out has helped in achieveing that
Bradmanesque average, which is actually testimony to his finishing skills.
In the first innings, he has batted 63 times and has
scored his runs at a strike-rate of 106 and an average of 57.
Just incredible.
He is India ’s
best no 6, though he is perfectly capable of playing higher up too.
If the recent past are anything to go by, we are seeing a rare skill on
decline. We have started expecting so much out of him that in the recent games
he has not been able to finish it as much as he would have liked to.
Take the world cup for example. Against Pakistan and South Africa , wonderful platform
had been created for a final push in the last five overs. He kept finding the
fielders and got out in both innings trying to pull a delivery. He couldn't finish
it like he always does. 18 of 13 and 18 of 11 against Pakistan and South Africa respetively just isn't Dhoni. He couldn't handle the pace and the bounce and a few boundaries hit against a wayward Wayne Parnell (nice twist isn't it?) of South Africa helped improve his score.
![]() |
Not 'THE' finisher anymore? |
Dhoni of the old could come in and get set to murder the
cricket ball almost immediately. Recently we are seeing that he is finding it
difficult to get going immediately and is taking his time.
He is milking singles and doubles but finding it tough
to get those boundaries he used to summon at will. The helicopter has not bee
seen in a while. Those last over sixes are declining.
"I'm 33," he had said
after India 's
World Cup exit. "I'm still running, I'm still fit." That he is. But
his batting specifically his hitting prowess has shown signs of decline. In the ongoing IPL he might play those blistering innings which may remove concerns of his finishing ability. However the fact is that he is
not able to do his role with that unnerving consistency that was his specialty.
So why not push him up the
order and give him an anchoring role after Virat Kohli. He is able to rotate
strike very well and is able to score at run-a-ball without taking too much of a
risk. He is still one of the best wicket-keeper batsman around if not the best,
at least in limited overs cricket in the country. All this calls for his promotion up the
order. If it weren't for Virat Kohli, I would say that he should come one down.
Ajinkya Rahane has had a
promising test career so far. An average in excess of 40 might not seem much
but look closer and you will see that he has played all but one test outside India . He has
cemented the no 5 spot and that century at lords on a seaming pitch still was one
of the greatest counter-attacks in recent times.
In contrast he has not yet been
able to show that consistency in the one-day format. A stop-start career did
not help. Apart from a free-flowing 79 against South Africa he hasn't made much of
an impact as middling average combined with a middling strike rate shows.
Batting at no 4, he has not yet
understood his role and has not been able to to find the right balance between attack with defense. Either
he plays too slowly as his innings against Bangladesh showed or he tries to
attack every delivery.
It will be good to push him
down the other at 5. Give him the role of finishing an innings. Let him be
clear of his role. If the past is anything to go by we have seen Rahane is at
his best when he is not bogged down by thoughts and when he plays instinctive
and free-flowing cricket. He is, on his day, a free flowing batsman.
Right now he is confused and is
continuously coming to bat in contrasting situations which he isn't able to
adapt to.
He just needs more time to find
his groove. An average in the 40s and a strike rate above 90 is what we need of
him.
Suresh Raina , should, unfortunately
for him come at 6 for the good of the team. We see that at present there is no
one else who has been able to finish games with his consistency( apart from MS Dhoni). An
average of 36 is misleading and tells us of what he could have become but i digress from our object of discussion.
This change in batting order will clear a lot of
problems which are definitely going to creep in if the Dhoni and Rahane do not
perform at 6 down and 4 down respectively. One will not finish effectively while the other will not anchor with consistency.
It is telling how effortlessly Rahane was playing Steyn and Morkel while Dhoni was clearly struggling to hit against their pace and bounce in that world
cup match.
It is time for a reversal in roles, don't you think?